I've seen other bloggers posting such lists and thought I'd join the club. In no particular order...
Christmas In Detroit - Various Artists (out of print)
Benefit CD produced in 1993 by various Detroit area musicians. Only one track I don't like.
An Evening in December - Various Artists
Some
of the best a cappella music ever recorded. Three of the four primary
vocalists on this CD eventually went on to form the group First Call.
When My Heart Finds Christmas - Harry Connick Jr.
How can you ever go wrong with Harry? Great fun.
The Christmas Album - The Manhattan Transfer
I've loved The Manhattan Transfer since high school. Great stuff and a great cameo by Tony Bennett. Can you tell I love vocals?
Come, Let Us Adore Him - Various Artists
The newest CD on the list. This is the 2005 collection created and organized by the guys from The Choir.
And finally, some Christmas CDs I wish I had...
Boogie Woogie Christmas - Brian Setzer Orchestra
Dig That Crazy Christmas - Brian Setzer Orchestra
Yes,
I just love Brian Setzer, especially his newer neo-swing stuff. Saw him
at Pine Knob (I still call it that) a few years ago...he was fantastic.
Broken Christmas - Various Artists
A CD done back in the early 90s by the artist stable of Broken Records. It's very rare, I'd love to find a copy.
A Charlie Brown Christmas - Vince Guaraldi Trio
Vince Guaraldi is fantastic, and so is Snoopy.

Messiah - George Frederic Handel
I
love the piece, of course, but I don't have a favorite recording of it.
Any suggestions? Please, don't say "The Young Messiah", Handel should
not be messed with in such ways.